​Cast decision in order of appearance:

• Narrator (VA: Ai-Chin Chen)

• Fan 1 (VA: Ponc via CCC)

• Fan 2 (VA: Jeff Rosenau via CCC)

• Nida Kruz (VA: Saphira Joy via e-mail)

• Ara Wilson (VA: Ruth Chenebach via CCC) 

• Oliver Michaelson (VA: Sean Sims via e-mail)

• Clair Voiance/Clair Riviera (VA: KyLeigh Zimmerer via CCC)

• Ren Faraday (VA: Josh Curtin Pini via CCC) 

• Bernie Bridges (VA: Jack Rendon via CCC)

• Fan 3 (VA: Altaz via CCC)

• Medic/Zeus (VA: James H via CCC)

• Aliya Nelson (VA: Tarrah Adam via CCC)

​

Next casting call for the third installment "Time Doesn't Heal All" will take place as early as November 2026.